This week on Facing the Future, host Bob Bixby spoke with Professor Sita Slavov of the Schar School of Public Policy at George Mason University. They discussed the impact of growing debt on the economy, the outlook for Social Security reform and the generational implications of doing nothing about either the debt or Social Security.
Slavov highlighted the immediate economic effects of rising debt, noting, “We’re already starting to feel the burden. Interest on the debt is more than $1 trillion. The other cost to having such a big debt is that if another crisis were to hit, such as a recession, or a pandemic, or a war, policymakers have very little room to maneuver. Debt was much lower when we went into the 2007-2008 financial crisis.”
She also explained that the growing debt has become an affordability issue: “When the government runs large deficits, there’s inflationary pressure and some of the inflation over recent years can be attributed to that. Moreover, when the government borrows money, it competes with private borrowers and that’s going to tend to push up interest rates and feed into the affordability of mortgages, car loans, things that really hit consumers.”
The debt-to-GDP ratio has reached levels last seen at the end of World War II. It came down quite a bit over the next few decades but Slavov cautioned that today’s challenges are more complex due to demographic and healthcare cost trends. “What’s contributing to the unsustainable growth of the debt is underlying trends: an aging population and healthcare costs,” she said. Unlike wartime defense spending, which can be reduced after the conflict, these costs are harder to control and have a lasting impact on the budget.
Slavov noted that while higher economic growth would help, “the problem is too big to grow our way out of because the debt is growing at an unsustainable rate.” She likened the risk of a debt-induced fiscal crisis to an earthquake: “You can say when the conditions are right for one, but it’s hard to predict exactly when or where.” Moreover, she suggested that a sudden crisis was less likely than a slow, gradual squeeze on government finances.
She pointed out, however, that the looming Social Security insolvency deadline would force policymakers to act and could influence financial markets’ confidence in the government’s fiscal management.
Her preferred fiscal solutions include transitioning Social Security to a flat benefit and imposing a carbon tax, but she noted, “those are obviously not the only options. I think the key is to be open to making adjustments on both sides of the budget and not saying ‘I absolutely will not cut spending, I absolutely will not raise taxes.’ It’s too late for that.”
A source of budget savings Slavov favors is closing tax loopholes, often referred to as “tax expenditures.” She explained: “There are a lot of tax expenditures, where the government is giving a tax break to a particular kind of activity; you can think about the home mortgage interest deduction, or the exclusion of employer-sponsored health insurance from people’s incomes. These are no different fundamentally than a subsidy for these activities. So it hits your wallet in exactly the same way, and it distorts the prices of these activities. It incentivizes people and their employers to have these very generous health insurance plans because they are effectively subsidized through the tax code. If you were to close or limit some of these tax expenditures, that would increase revenue. It might also improve incentives and economic efficiency.”
Among other revenue options, she expressed skepticism about the effectiveness of wealth taxes, citing their high administrative costs and uncertain revenue potential. “There was a time,” she noted, “when many European countries actually had wealth taxes. They actually have very high administrative costs compared to the revenue that they raise. If you think about countries that have very generous social programs, like the countries of Western Europe, they’re imposing higher taxes broadly on the population, on the middle class. They’ve got things like value-added taxes, which are essentially consumption taxes, and the middle class is paying for that. So, I think it’s kind of unrealistic to have very generous social programs that are paid for primarily by one small sliver of society. We’re going to have to think about the trade-offs, in terms of broad-based taxes for everyone.”
Hear more on Facing the Future. Concord Coalition Senior Advisor Bob Bixby hosts the program each week on WKXL in Concord N.H., and it is also available via podcast. Join us as The Concord Coalition team discusses issues relating to national fiscal policy with budget experts, industry leaders, and elected officials. Past broadcasts are available here. You can subscribe to the podcast on Spotify, Pandora, iTunes, Google Podcasts, Stitcher, or with an RSS feed. Follow Facing the Future on Facebook, and watch videos from past episodes on The Concord Coalition YouTube channel.
Continue Reading